The tension he built meant anyone in the audience was ready

OurBrightFuture u

speed of sound 21 points submitted 13 hours ago

I was alright with it for the first few days. But then I started realizing the parts I didn like were worse than I initially thought.

I think Disney biggest miscalculation was that people were mostly into Star Wars for the aesthetic and universe. For me the biggest part is the story of the Skywalker family. A story which now Canada Goose Jackets ends in a life of never ending tragedy for Leia, and Luke becoming a broken, out of character failure. I just can accept that.

Canada Goose Jackets At least in the old EU buy canada goose jacket we had canadagoosejacketoutlett.com the Skywalker family together, Luke fulfilling his destiny, a better version of the evil son, and a believable female protagonist on her way to becoming a Jedi master. Canada Goose Jackets

cheap Canada Goose JBaecker 18 points submitted 7 days ago cheap Canada Goose

To expand on one point: you don always need to be consistent. But the number of inconsistencies is something that audiences WILL keep track of and too many are what really do in the suspension of disbelief. My favorite example of this is Jaws. (Smile, you sonofabitch!)

From the making Jaws documentary;

I said “Steven, that is completely unbelievable. It can’t happen. A shark does not bite down on a SCUBA tank and explode like an oil refinery.” He said, “I don’t care.” He said, “If I have got them for two hours, they will believe whatever I do for the next three minutes because I’ve got them in my canada goose hands, and I want the canadian goose jacket audience on their feet screaming at the end, ‘Yes, yes! This is what should happen to this animal!'” Reality may canada goose coats on sale be great and truth may be wonderful, but none of it holds a candle to believability. His ending brought people to their feet, screaming.

uk canada goose outlet I got them for two hours is the important part. It doesn matter that the exploding scuba tank is completely and totally unbelievable. It the fact that for Canada Goose sale two hours, Spielberg showed the people chasing Jaws doing things and the shark kept fucking them up. The tension he built meant anyone in the audience was ready for that exact moment where Roy Scheider utters what is one of the most bad ass lines of all time. You don care that reality has been violated. You just care that Jaw head just exploded and that Roy and Richard Dreyfuss Canada Goose Outlet are going to escape. Because he built his story properly that the one moment of complete unbelievability just doesn matter. TLJ doesn do that, it just stacks moment upon moment, asking the audience for just one more silly, canada goose store stupid, idiotic, or outright unbelievable thing. uk canada goose outlet

canada goose coats mattxl 1 point submitted 7 days ago canada goose coats

We do know the mistake that was the breaking point for Luke. betraying the trust of his student by even thinking about killing him and, in turn, causing the student to murder Canada Goose online all of his other students and creating a new villain. like that is a big mistake for him and in line with Luke from the OT who frequently would get too passionate about things and then get close canada goose deals to making a really poor choice, or making one, like in ESB when he decides to leave his training to run off and get Han captured and get his hand cut off. This particular mistake of his canada goose coats passion canada goose black friday sale just had much harsher consequences that weighed on him.

betraying the trust of his student by even thinking about killing him and, in turn, causing the student to murder all of canada goose clearance his other students and creating a new villain.

canada goose black friday sale Why would he betray his student trust if he learned from experience that trusting and believing in his family and friends will pay off? canada goose black friday sale

canada goose coats on sale like that is a big mistake for him and in line with Luke from the OT who frequently would get too passionate about things and then get close to making a really poor choice, or making one, like in ESB when he decides to leave his training to run off and get Han captured and get his hand cut off. This particular mistake of his passion just had much harsher consequences that weighed on him. canada goose coats on sale

But he learned from this mistake before in ROTJ, he took a whole year off to train and prepare to save Han and Vader.

The above example is really good since it shows that Luke learns very well from his mistakes and change for the better.

uk canada goose OurBrightFuture 1 point submitted 7 days ago uk canada goose

canada goose uk black friday in the past when similar stuff happened it was typically something that affected him or others in a way that was repairable. canada goose uk black friday

canadian goose jacket Ah sorry I didn get this line, are you saying that they faced problems in the past that could be repairable but somehow not this one? canadian goose jacket

Canada Goose Online And I was really hoping that you answered my questions in the previous post above: Canada Goose Online

Canada Goose Outlet what made Luke reach that exact decision when he successfully solved that problem before. He knows people are redeemable. Canada Goose Outlet

Canada Goose online You said Luke betrayed his student trust. But why would he betray his student trust if he learned from experience that trusting and believing in his family and friends will pay off? Canada Goose online

canada goose uk shop zootskippedagroove6 2 points submitted 8 days ago canada goose uk shop

I didn really want Luke to be prominent, I actually wanted them to leave the OT alone entirely and try something buy canada goose jacket cheap new, but maybe that just me. I just wanted to see Master Jedi Luke, not some old dude who makes me depressed every time he on screen. cheap Canada Goose I mean even Hamill himself was like “yeah bros, this ain Luke”. It was honestly sad to watch.

With the Yoda comparison, at least he was still likeable. Luke was just depressing. If we had seen young Luke after TLJ, I would think “wow, something must messed him up that hasn even been mentioned yet”, because nothing in TLJ helps me understand why Luke is the way he is. They tried to replicate the whole “goofy old dude is actually a huge badass”, but it failed in every respect. Again, all my opinion and I respect all the people who enjoyed it.

OurBrightFuture 2 points submitted 8 days ago

canada goose uk outlet I just wanted to see Master Jedi Luke, not some old dude who makes me depressed every time he on screen. I mean even Hamill himself was like “yeah bros, this ain Luke”. It was honestly sad to watch. canada goose uk outlet

I read yesterday someone complaining how his kids started crying when they were watching the canada goose outlet movie, saying “that not Luke!”, I truly felt bad for them lol.

canada goose clearance really don mind deconstructing the protagonist, it would be something interesting to watch. But what they did here is strip Luke from everything he is, and take everything he ever learned in his journey canada goose clearance.

Related Posts in Category Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published nor share. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>